Fees8 min read·14 November 2026·Last fact-checked 14 November 2026

In-specie transfer vs selling and rebuying when you switch brokers

By Thanos Karantonis · Economist

Compare moving investments without selling with a cash transfer, including transfer fees, currency conversion and time out of the market.

Key takeaway

Compare the transfer quote by holding with the full cost of selling and repurchasing. An in-specie move keeps market exposure but may restrict trading; a cash move creates time out of the market and may realise taxable gains or losses.

An in-specie transfer moves eligible shares or fund units to another broker without selling them. A cash transfer sells the holdings, moves the proceeds and allows you to repurchase investments at the receiving broker. The choice is not simply between a transfer fee and a dealing commission: eligibility, currency conversion, tax and time out of the market can change the result.

What changes when you move investments without selling?

During an in-specie move you keep market exposure: the shares or fund units remain invested as their price changes. However, trading may be restricted while the transfer is being processed, so you may not be able to sell or adjust a position when you want to. Ask both providers about restrictions and expected processing times rather than assuming that continued exposure means uninterrupted access.

The receiving broker must confirm eligibility for each ISIN, quantity and account type. A listing with a similar name is not enough. Ask separately whether fractional holdings can move and whether recurring orders can be carried over or must be cancelled and recreated. Partial transfers may be possible, depending on both providers and the account: you may be able to move supported positions while making a separate plan for unsupported holdings.

For regulatory context on investment-platform switching, see the FCA’s investment platforms policy statement PS19/29. It is UK context, not a guarantee that every broker or security supports an in-specie transfer.

Price the cash route on both sides

For selling and rebuying, compare both legs’ commissions, the spread and every applicable currency conversion. Establish whether the sale proceeds remain in the investment’s currency or are converted into your account currency, and what happens when you fund and execute the repurchase. Include outgoing and incoming cash charges where relevant. Our guide to understanding broker fees explains the separate cost categories.

Use realistic executable sale and purchase quotes for the same quantity. If those quotes already capture the bid–ask spread, do not add that spread again as a separate charge. Alternatively, estimate spread costs against a consistent reference price, but do not mix the two approaches and double count them. Market and exchange-rate movements during the transfer are separate from fees.

Worked comparison: one US holding in a Freetrade UK GIA

Fees checked 14 November 2026. Freetrade’s GIA transfer guidance quotes £17 per US holding for outgoing transfers processed through The Depository Trust Company (DTC). The Basic plan offers zero dealing commission and charges 0.99% FX on non-GBP trades, also set out in its FX-fee explanation. These are Freetrade UK GIA examples, not prices for every broker, account or transfer route.

The table models one eligible holding, a £0 incoming charge, and constant market prices and FX rates. It assumes the Basic sale of the non-GBP holding incurs the 0.99% FX charge on its sterling-equivalent value. Repurchase costs, spreads, taxes and other charges are excluded from the table. This is a sale-side FX-only comparison, not a complete switching-cost quote.

Holding value (GBP)In-specie transfer fee (GBP)Sale-side FX at 0.99% (GBP)Difference before repurchase
£1,000£17.00£9.90£7.10 remains for all other execution costs before the cash route matches the transfer fee.
£5,000£17.00£49.50Sale-side FX alone is £32.50 higher than the transfer fee, before repurchase.

At £1,000, £17 − £9.90 = £7.10 is the remaining budget for all other execution costs before matching the transfer fee. At £5,000, £49.50 − £17 = £32.50 is already an excess cost before any repurchase. Neither result says the excluded costs are zero.

The sale-side FX-only threshold is £17 ÷ 0.0099 ≈ £1,717. It is not an all-in break-even point: adding repurchase, spread, tax or other costs changes the comparison. Position count also matters: five eligible US holdings at £17 each cost £85 to transfer, even if their combined value equals that of a single holding.

Ready to put this into practice?

See the brokers our team recommends for fees.

Interactive Brokers

Interactive Brokers

9.7

Advanced Investors

Trade Republic

Trade Republic

9.4

Beginners and DCA investors building long-term ETF portfolios

Time out of the market is not a transfer fee

On the cash route, a +1% sterling-equivalent price move on £5,000 means approximately £50 more is needed to buy back the same quantity; a −1% move means approximately £50 less. This is a separate price-movement illustration, not an extra fee and not a forecast. A move in either the investment price or the exchange rate can affect the sterling-equivalent repurchase amount. The cash route may miss rises or avoid falls, whereas an in-specie position stays exposed but may not be tradable during the move.

Tax and account type: GIA is not ISA

The UK GIA worked example is pre-tax. Selling may realise capital gains or losses; the tax consequences depend on your circumstances and the applicable rules. Retain acquisition dates, cost basis, trade confirmations and corporate-action records, and check what records the receiving broker imports. Do not assume that moving providers resets the acquisition cost or that the new broker’s display is a complete tax record.

A UK Stocks and Shares ISA transfer should go through the receiving provider, using the provider’s ISA transfer process. Cash or in-specie routes depend on the providers and investments involved. Withdrawing money personally instead of transferring through the provider may affect your ability to reinvest within ISA rules. Check the government’s ISA transfer guidance and your providers’ procedures before acting; do not treat an ordinary withdrawal and deposit as an ISA transfer.

Five-step broker-switching checklist

1. List the positions precisely

Record each ISIN, quantity, fractional amount and currency. Identify the account type and any holdings you do not want to move.

2. Confirm the receiving broker’s acceptance

Get confirmation of eligibility and incoming fees for the exact holdings and account. Ask separately about fractions and whether a partial transfer is supported.

3. Obtain an outgoing quote by holding

Ask the current broker for a quote covering each holding and the applicable transfer route, including any additional charges. A per-position fee makes the number of holdings as important as portfolio value.

4. Price both legs of the cash route

Compare sale and repurchase commissions, executable quotes, exchange costs and tax implications. Avoid counting a spread twice, and allow for time out of the market rather than assuming prices will remain constant.

5. Plan the loose ends

Agree what happens to unsupported holdings, dividends and cash arriving after the move. Retain acquisition records, and cancel or recreate recurring orders as needed so they do not execute unexpectedly. Confirm completion with both providers before closing the old account.

This article is educational, not personal investment or tax advice. Investments can fall in value. Confirm the current charges and account-specific transfer process with both providers before switching.

Topics:Broker transfersIn-specie transferFX feesISA

Our top picks for this topic

Compare regulated European brokers side-by-side

Hand-selected brokers that match what this guide covers.

Interactive Brokers

Interactive Brokers

9.7

Advanced Investors

Trade Republic

Trade Republic

9.4

Beginners and DCA investors building long-term ETF portfolios

DEGIRO

DEGIRO

8.5

Cost-conscious European stock and ETF investors

Thanos Karantonis

Economist

Thanos Karantonis is an economist and member of the Economic Chamber of Greece. He holds a Bachelor’s degree in Business Administration from the University of Macedonia, with a focus on Marketing. He is Head of Commercial at Financial Europeans, Europe’s first finfluencer agency, where he leads commercial growth. At InvestBeacon, he writes about European investment platforms, broker fees and investing.

Published 14 November 2026

All guides are independently researched and updated regularly. We may earn a commission when you open an account through our links, at no cost to you.

Related

Keep reading

Newsletter

Our weekly digest is on the way.

We're not collecting sign-ups yet. Once our provider is in place we'll open subscriptions with a full opt-in and privacy notice.

Coming soon

Contact

Work with InvestBeacon

For partnerships, compliance matters or general editorial questions, you can contact the InvestBeacon team directly. We do not provide personal financial advice or individualized investment recommendations.

Paid collaborations

For broker partnerships, affiliate opportunities, media collaborations and commercial inquiries.

partnerships@investbeacon.eu

Compliance

For regulatory, disclosure, accuracy or compliance-related requests.

compliance@investbeacon.eu

General questions

For editorial questions, corrections, feedback or general contact.

team@investbeacon.eu

Any communication through these email addresses takes place outside the platform and should not be interpreted as personal financial advice or an individualized investment recommendation.